Dr. Brian Choi
A Psychiatrist on 5150 Holds, Psych Meds & Agency - EP 38 Overview
Dr. Brian Choi is a psychiatrist who almost never became one. Raised in a family of physicians, with OB-GYNs, a pediatrician, a nephrologist, a colorectal surgeon and an ER physician among his relatives, he entered medical school on a path toward anesthesia. Today he runs Better Choices, a cash-pay psychiatry practice based in Orange County that sees patients virtually throughout California, and his approach to care looks very different from the quick medication check most people expect from a psychiatrist.
Before opening his practice, Dr. Choi spent seven years as the medical director of an inpatient psychiatric unit, where he treated everything from suicidality and bipolar disorder to schizophrenia, personality disorders and addiction. That front-line experience gives him a rare view of how the system really works: insurance companies pushing patients out the door before they are ready, 5150 holds and involuntary treatment, the legal process behind forced medication, and the patients who keep cycling back because nobody on the outpatient side has time to get to the root of the problem.
Justin and Dr. Choi dig into what America is getting right and wrong about mental health, from reduced stigma and wider access to therapy, to private equity buying up clinics and turning complex human struggles into 7.5 minute appointments. They break down the positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia, how antipsychotics block dopamine and why their side effects can mimic Parkinson's disease, and the idea that the human brain would rather be persecuted than forgotten. They also explore metabolic psychiatry, the gut-brain connection, research on the ketogenic diet for schizophrenia, and why modern food and doom scrolling deliver dopamine hits our caveman brains were never built to handle.
At the heart of the conversation is Dr. Choi's framework for change. Your brain's goal, he argues, is not happiness but efficiency: it turns whatever you repeat into autopilot, and too often that leaves you dragged behind the car instead of sitting in the driver's seat. Getting a patient's sense of agency back, cleaning up overloaded medication lists, setting goals worth aiming for instead of just running from "anywhere but here," and anticipating the tricks the brain will use to resist change are the tools he uses to move patients from symptom reduction to actually thriving.
Dr. Choi also opens up about his own depression in medical school, when everything on paper was going right and he still sat in cafes wishing he could be any stranger who was smiling. A personal SWOT analysis during the business school year of his combined MD MBA program led him away from anesthesia and toward psychiatry, a field he says chose him. Now a new father, he is thinking about how to put these ideas into a book that helps parents teach their kids what school never will.
Topics Discussed
Moving beyond symptom reduction toward goals and thriving
The rearview mirror analogy and focusing on the future
Private equity, profit and the quality of mental health care
Insurance companies and inpatient psychiatric discharges
5150, 5250 and 5270 holds in California
Conservatorship, grave disability and the Riese petition for involuntary medication
Positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia
How dopamine and antipsychotic side effects work in the brain
Metabolic psychiatry, GLP-1 medications and the gut-brain axis
Dopamine, junk food and doom scrolling
Why the brain prioritizes efficiency and runs on autopilot
Seven-minute med checks and the problem of too many psych meds
Cash-pay psychiatry and practicing outside of insurance
Depression in medical school and choosing psychiatry
Rebuilding a sense of agency to create lasting change and sobriety
People Mentioned
Dr. DeLuise
A clinician Justin references whose work with a long-hospitalized schizophrenia patient helped the man become medication free and a self-supporting artist.
Luigi Mangione
The man charged in the killing of the UnitedHealthcare CEO. Justin and Dr. Choi discuss the public reaction as a sign of how deep frustration with insurance companies runs, while agreeing the act itself was wrong.
Concepts Discussed
The Brain's Goal Is Efficiency
Dr. Choi teaches patients that the brain is not trying to make them happy. Like Pavlov's dog, it turns repeated behavior into an efficient autopilot, and change is hard because it demands energy the brain would rather save.
Getting Back in the Driver's Seat
His image for losing agency: being dragged behind the car by a rope while the brain drives. Treatment moves the patient step by step, from behind the car to the trunk, the back seat, the passenger seat and finally the driver's seat.
Persecuted Rather Than Forgotten
Antipsychotics can quiet tormenting hallucinations, but for some patients the emptiness and isolation that follow are even more painful. Real recovery from schizophrenia requires community and purpose, not only medication.
Aim for a Destination, Not "Anywhere but Here"
People who only want to escape where they are tend to circle the place they hate. Defining who you want to become gives you a direction to measure against and correct toward.
Built-In Inefficiency
Dr. Choi argues that insurance companies benefit from their own friction: when denials and hold times wear down doctors and patients, care that should be covered never gets reviewed.
Connect with Dr. Brian Choi & Better Choices Psychiatry
Timestamps
00:00:00 Introduction: Why life after depression is where the real work starts
A Psychiatrist's Approach to Mental Health
(00:01:38) Meet Dr. Brian Choi of Better Choices
(00:02:16) The rearview mirror analogy: focus on where you're going
(00:04:26) How an MBA shaped his approach to psychiatry
(00:06:41) What America gets right and wrong about mental health
(00:07:15) Less stigma, more therapy, but what about quality?
(00:09:10) Private equity in mental health and addiction treatment
(00:10:18) Seven years as an inpatient psychiatry medical director
5150 Holds & Involuntary Psychiatric Treatment
(00:13:15) 5150, 5250 and 5270 holds explained
(00:14:45) Conservatorship and the right to refuse medication
(00:16:38) Addiction, agency and constitutional rights
(00:17:32) The weight of taking someone's rights away
(00:18:47) Horror stories from involuntary psychiatric holds
(00:20:41) When families want patients held longer
Schizophrenia, Dopamine & Antipsychotic Side Effects
(00:23:52) Severe schizophrenia and the Riese petition
(00:24:33) Pill pusher? Why medications matter in inpatient psychiatry
(00:27:06) Positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia
(00:28:32) The brain would rather be persecuted than forgotten
(00:33:05) Dopamine in the brain and why delivery is the problem
(00:34:27) Antipsychotic side effects and Parkinson-like symptoms
(00:35:53) Genetics, family history and addiction risk
Metabolic Psychiatry, Diet & Dopamine
(00:38:40) Metabolic psychiatry, GLP-1s and the gut-brain axis
(00:39:55) Fecal transplants and the ketogenic diet for schizophrenia
(00:42:23) Caveman Justin and the Twizzlers time machine
(00:43:41) Doom scrolling and faster dopamine hits
(00:45:20) Getting your sense of agency back
Brain Efficiency, Autopilot & Too Many Psych Meds
(00:47:04) Your brain's goal is efficiency, not happiness
(00:52:04) Your brain isn't broken, it needs reprogramming
(00:53:22) Why inpatient psychiatric hospitals are disappearing
(00:53:57) Seven-minute med checks and polypharmacy
(00:56:35) Coming off psych meds to find a baseline
(01:00:55) Why a bad day shouldn't mean a higher dose
Chemical Imbalance, Insurance & Cash-Pay Psychiatry
(01:01:22) Is mental illness purely chemical?
(01:04:22) A schizophrenia patient who became medication free
(01:05:47) Insurance denials and built-in inefficiencies
(01:08:57) The UnitedHealthcare CEO shooting and public reaction
(01:09:57) Why Dr. Choi doesn't take insurance
(01:13:29) Better Choices: who he treats today
(01:15:58) The DSM, diagnosis and patients who don't fit the box
(01:18:53) Remission isn't the finish line
Depression in Medical School & Finding Psychiatry
(01:23:18) A family of doctors and the path to anesthesia
(01:23:56) Depression in medical school
(01:25:55) The personal SWOT analysis that changed his career
Agency, Goals & Reprogramming Your Autopilot
(01:29:22) From being dragged behind the car to the driver's seat
(01:32:18) Low-hanging fruit and ice cream homework
(01:34:48) Why anywhere but here keeps you stuck
(01:38:46) How your brain fights against change
(01:42:26) Reprogramming autopilot for lasting sobriety
(01:44:01) Trauma, self-worth and setting goals
(01:46:18) Fatherhood and a future book for parents
(01:48:08) Why mental health is a national security issue
(01:50:19) Only one of us has to have hope
Transcript
(00:00:12) Brian Choi: It's not just about treating their symptoms. So my, my hope is that we can minimize symptoms, reduce symptoms, and then work past that. Okay, now that we got the depression under control, now that we got your anxiety under control, now is a good starting point to say, now who do you want to be now that what was holding you back is not there anymore? Now let's start the fun work. Let's start thinking about what your goals are, what your relationships are going to look like now that you're not depressed. And then we define these goals and then we work towards that. So in my practice it's not just about, okay, you're depressed, here's your PHQ-9, right. I looked at the PHQ-9, right. And all it's asking you is all these negative things, right. And if you answer zero to all of them, yeah, okay, you're not depressed. But does that mean you're happy?
(00:01:01) Justin McMillen: Right.
(00:01:02) Brian Choi: Do you have something that you're working towards that you're going to be fulfilled by? Have you made up for the relationships that were broken when you were depressed? Right. So there's that component of, now let's move past this, this cage of depression. You're free now. And now let's work towards something that you want to become.
(00:01:25) Justin McMillen: That's a, that's... I really, really appreciate what you're saying, Doctor Choi. I want to welcome you to the show. And you are a psychiatrist with Better Choice Psychiatry.
(00:01:36) Brian Choi: Better Choices.
(00:01:38) Justin McMillen: Better Choices. Excuse me. And, I'm just glad to have you here today. And we've been talking a little bit about, your approach to this work. And I think it's already immediately clear to me that you're coming at mental health in a different way than most people. And it sounds like you're, you're focused on what's happening out in the future versus what happened in the past. Is that fair?
(00:02:03) Brian Choi: Yeah. There's a lot that you can learn from the past. There's a lot of analogies that I give. A lot of it has to do with cars, but one of the ones that I give...
(00:02:14) Justin McMillen: Do you like cars?
(00:02:16) Brian Choi: I love, love cars. Now with relation to that is, okay, why is the rearview mirror so much smaller than our front windshield? Right? Because you shouldn't be focusing all of your energy looking behind you. It's very important that you have that rearview mirror so you can see where other cars are, what's going on around you. But the size difference between our front windshield and the rearview mirror is huge, because the importance is looking ahead.
(00:02:44) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:02:45) Brian Choi: So there's a lot of things that you can get from the past, but I think that work is usually, for me and my patients, it usually happens after we focus on understanding where we're going.
(00:02:58) Justin McMillen: Wow. Is there a name for this kind of approach?
(00:03:03) Brian Choi: I don't know, this is, I, I've developed this just from my own experience, from talking with my patients. It's, I don't have a name for it. There might be a name out there. I'm sure it's not a new concept, but it's something that just makes sense to me. And I think that's, that's where my strength comes from, is, you know, when I tell people that I'm a psychiatrist, some people immediately jump to, are you psychoanalyzing me? And it's like, yeah, no, that's not, that's not what I do. But I realize that that's sort of how my brain works and psychiatry just fit into it. So it's, it's something that works for me. It's not that I have to turn on my therapist brain. It's like when I'm talking to people, sometimes I just have to hold back and say, okay, we're just having a conversation. We're not trying to dive into figuring out this problem, but I've always been fascinated with processes, with system improvement. And I think that, you know, from a systems level, it helped me when I was working in the hospital, but it also helped me on an individual level to try to understand what somebody is going through and then figure out how we can be doing that better.
(00:04:19) Justin McMillen: Yeah, that makes sense. I, your background, you, you have an education in some business too, right?
(00:04:25) Brian Choi: Yes.
(00:04:26) Justin McMillen: So, so, so that, how do you think that that played a role in, how you said systems level thinking, is that helped you to sort of frame out how to approach this work?
(00:04:35) Brian Choi: Absolutely. It's, it's a different part of the brain that doesn't really get exercised through the medical education.
(00:04:42) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(00:04:43) Brian Choi: Right. They, they teach you how to think like a doctor. They teach you how to come up with a differential diagnosis. And in medical school and residency, you're in the system, working in the system, but not thinking about how you can necessarily improve the system. Right. As a resident there's a lot of things that we've gone through that just doesn't make sense. And then you ask, why are we doing it this way? And then a lot of times the response is, I went through it, so you have to go through it. This is just the way that it's always been done. And that never sat well with me.
(00:05:17) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:05:18) Brian Choi: So from that standpoint, the, that wasn't necessarily the reason why I got my MBA. But I think looking at things differently helped me see that there are a lot of ways that we can be doing things better.
(00:05:32) Justin McMillen: So you're, you're safe to say that you're a really strong micro macro thinker. You zoom in and out constantly.
(00:05:40) Brian Choi: Yeah. Because I think it's very important that you are looking not only at the details, but then seeing how you can operate within the systems.
(00:05:50) Justin McMillen: Right.
(00:05:51) Brian Choi: It's very important from an individual level, but it's also important from a much bigger level, so that you're understanding the problem that you can apply across the board. And that's how, you know, one of the things that they're teaching us, again, in residency is a research paper comes out and you're reading it and you're trying to see who can I apply this to and who does it not apply to. So if you just take the conclusion and say, I'm going to apply this to all my patients, you're actually missing the point of the research because they have the demographics, they have the exclusion criteria, they have the inclusion criteria. And that's very important to figure out, okay, for this group, this specific group, we can find something that will work.
(00:06:32) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(00:06:34) Brian Choi: But for this other group this research actually doesn't apply to them. So we need to expand research further.
(00:06:41) Justin McMillen: What a... so based on the fact that you're a systems level thinker, I think you're a bit of a first principles thinker as well. You seem to boil things down to the basic ideas. What is it that America is getting wrong about our approach to mental health and what are we getting right? We'll make it positive at the end.
(00:07:03) Brian Choi: Yeah.
(00:07:05) Justin McMillen: I'm sure you have some opinions about this. And do not be afraid to be bold and say what you think. And, people like strong opinions. I mean, it's, it's not...
(00:07:15) Brian Choi: Yeah. Yeah. So I think there's a big shift now where mental health has been... A lot less taboo than it used to be. Right now you're looking on, you know, any social media platform, any video platform, one of the biggest advertisers, and I don't know if it's just because of my algorithm, but it's BetterHelp. Right. Everybody, all the influencers are talking about, oh, today I went to therapy, and I think that is great. Right. I think the access to mental health is something that should continue to grow and that more people need access. Now where I think that it's, might be going the other way or we could make improvements on is, comes down to quality. Right. So just because you have a therapist doesn't necessarily mean that that therapist is doing good work. Just because you have a psychiatrist doesn't mean that the medications or whatever the treatment that they're offering is what you should, what's actually going to help you. Right. The problem becomes where those systems, who's controlling those systems and what the ultimate end product or goal of that system is. And just like other profitable spaces, private equity is getting into mental health clinics. And the, the lens of the private equity is how do we optimize to increase profits, not how do we optimize for health? How do we optimize for outcomes? Right. It's how do we see more people? How do we turn somebody's struggles into an algorithm and a checklist so that you can fit the complexities of mood and personality and behavior into 7.5 minute appointments every few months?
(00:09:10) Justin McMillen: Yeah. It's, it's... this is the dark side of private equity. I don't know this for sure, but I think that one of the things that's maybe attractive about our space to, so in substance use disorder, we've had several people try to acquire us over the years. And it's attractive because you have recurring clients. And unfortunately being good at your work, is, is not mission aligned with making money. So what I mean by that is we will make more money when our clients are sicker. And that's a harsh fact, that there's more money to be made when people relapse. There's more money to be made when somebody needs two sessions a week instead of one, or their medication needs to be changed. And I think if you're just looking at the world through profit and you're coming from that space in private equity, they show up and they go, this is kind of a perfect business model, because we're not saying being better at this is really just your patient failing, because our definition of being better means more profit. And so I think the solution, Doctor Choi, is value based care and performance based reimbursement models.
(00:10:18) Brian Choi: Yeah, I mean that's, that's sort of hits at the frustrations that I experienced on the hospital side. So I spent seven years as the medical director for an inpatient unit. And the amount of times that the team, the treatment team, which involves nurses, social workers, mental health workers... Occupational therapists, myself, that we would sit around during rounds to discuss insurance companies telling us that the patient needs to go home. Right. That something very serious is going on, and, but they have decided without ever seeing the patient that they don't need to be in the hospital anymore. And that comes down to value, right. That comes down to, in their minds it's cheaper to get them out of the hospital where care is very expensive and into an outpatient setting without concern for what the outcomes could be, because if something bad happens, they can always come back and say, we're not the decision maker. You should have kept them in the hospital. Why are you worried about money, man? You should, you know, you should stick to what you believe is important, even though from the hospital side, administration is looking at, okay, we have this many patients on your unit. How come we aren't being paid by insurance for X amount of patients? And you can't say, well, insurance thinks they need to go, but I think they need to stay. So there's always that conflict from what is best for the patient, and then who's paying for that.
(00:12:02) Justin McMillen: Well, how is it that, you maybe don't know the answer to this question, but why does the, why do the insurance companies believe that they have a better idea of what's best for patients than the doctors?
(00:12:15) Brian Choi: I don't know if they, if it comes down to that they have a better idea. But I think what they're trying to correct for is mistakes that the insurance companies made in medicine a long time ago.
(00:12:28) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:12:29) Brian Choi: And what I mean by that is, I come from a family of doctors. So my, my mom, my grandma's a doctor. I have uncles and aunts, they're doctors, and back, I call this the heyday of medicine for physicians, is like the late 80s, early 90s. The payment model was cost plus. So whatever the physician decided to order, you can just tack on a percentage points and that's what they would get reimbursed.
(00:12:57) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:12:58) Brian Choi: So you have an irresponsible method of payment because the more you order, the more you get paid. And that for a responsible physician isn't a problem. But you can see how for somebody who wants to maximize...
(00:13:13) Justin McMillen: Unnecessary tests.
(00:13:15) Brian Choi: Absolutely. Right. And then that's where, inappropriate referrals came from. You can have a network of doctors where one patient will enter the circle, be referred to all their buddies. All these tests will be ordered. And from one patient, everybody's lining their pockets. So now that's not the case anymore. But you still have, especially in the inpatient side, where you aren't necessarily treating, but you're holding. And I think only, not think, I know only in mental health can somebody, can somebody's rights be taken away and be kept in a hospital. Right. So you have 5150, 5250. So for those that aren't familiar with that, 5150 in California is an up to 72 hour involuntary hold. And then that can get extended to a 5250, which is an up to 14 day involuntary hold. And then that can get extended further to a 5270. And of course, there's criteria for all of this. But that can be up to 30 days. And there's even ways for somebody who has chronic mental illness, who can't keep themselves out of the hospital, that they can be put on something called a conservatorship, where their rights are taken away, given to a conservator who then makes decisions for them regarding hospitalization and care.
(00:14:44) Justin McMillen: Wow.
(00:14:45) Brian Choi: And it can go further beyond that to where somebody's rights to refuse medications, it can be determined that they do not have the capacity to make medication decisions for themselves. Now, there's a legal process to all of this. It goes in front of hearing officers and judges, and there's patients, or there's people who represent the hospital. There's people who represent the patient. And for somebody to be determined that they do not have the capacity to make medication decisions for themselves, then the treatment team, the physician, gets to make that decision. And if they refuse medications, then they're given medications against their will.
(00:15:24) Justin McMillen: Wow. That's unbelievable. So you can, makes sense, because people can be... so for people who don't know, if you're a danger to yourself or others.
(00:15:34) Brian Choi: Right.
(00:15:35) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:15:36) Brian Choi: And now this third, the third category is for grave disability.
(00:15:41) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:15:42) Brian Choi: Inability to take, inability to take care of one's clothing, food and shelter. So it's a very low bar. But that's being expanded now. It used to not be able, substances used to not be covered under that. But now they're seeing that somebody who is actively under the influence, who's not able to care for themselves, can fall under those categories.
(00:16:03) Justin McMillen: Is this federal or is it just in the state?
(00:16:06) Brian Choi: State by state.
(00:16:08) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:16:09) Brian Choi: So there are, that's for California specifically. There are similar laws in different states, but some of them don't, they have a shorter one and then a much longer one. So we have sort of a stepwise approach, but I think every state has this ability to take somebody who can't, who's not in the right mind, who may be a danger to themselves, danger to somebody else, or who can't seem to be taking care of their basic needs, and against their will, send them to a hospital for treatment.
(00:16:38) Justin McMillen: The only thing, I think about this a lot because it's so interesting, is substance abuse specifically, because if you're, the decision maker being the brain is impaired, and then expecting that person to make a decision to stop seems like a bit of a paradox, right? It's like, how, how can we expect this all to happen? You have to find a moment of clarity with that person, especially if they've been ten years on the street. So how do you interrupt that cycle long enough to say, okay, this person has enough agency to make a decision, and it seems a little bit futile that we expect they'll do that on their own. So I've always wondered about this, but then you have, like, basic human rights, right? At what point is a person not in their right mind to where they don't have the same constitutional rights as everyone else?
(00:17:28) Brian Choi: Yeah, it's a fascinating...
(00:17:31) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:17:32) Brian Choi: I mean, you bring up that word agency and it's so important. And I've told, my approach, while that was something that I did while I was in the hospital, not anything that I do anymore, but I would tell patients, I would tell patients' family members that this is one of the most serious and important parts of my job, is to make the determination of taking somebody's rights away.
(00:17:58) Justin McMillen: Right.
(00:17:59) Brian Choi: Which only happens in a mental health hospital or when they go to jail or prison. Right. You're literally taking somebody's rights away, which is, in America, the last thing that you would ever want to do.
(00:18:13) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(00:18:14) Brian Choi: So it has to be serious enough for them to need it. You have to justify it. But then at the same time, you're saying that this person who can't stand up for themselves, somebody... What, the system is sort of built against them, and that can be abused by, for somebody who doesn't really care about what the patient needs, for somebody who just wants somebody to stay in the hospital longer so you can get more reimbursement from an insurance company.
(00:18:46) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:18:47) Brian Choi: Right. There are, there are horror stories of people being put on hold, and they don't know when the last time they saw the psychiatrist was. The law says that on a hold, you need to be evaluated by a psychiatrist every single day of that hold. Now, does that mean that the note isn't being put in and that day is not being billed for? No, absolutely, it's being done. But the patient doesn't know who they're talking to, why they went from one hold to the next hold. And in many cases, yeah, the patient might not be in the right state of mind to remember this or to say, yeah, that was the person that I talked to. But at the same time, there are times when they weren't talked to.
(00:19:34) Justin McMillen: Wow. This gets my head going because you think about... If you think about this, the where this could go, is that the definition of what to define when someone is not capable of making good choices, if that's left up to the state, and then we end up with a crazy situation on the state level where they say, well, a person who doesn't understand that this is the best leader probably doesn't have a good brain. And so we're going to say that you're unfit to... Do you see how that, I mean, it could get crazy.
(00:20:11) Brian Choi: It's a very delicate situation.
(00:20:14) Justin McMillen: And then to think anybody who is deemed mentally unfit is not going to be able to go out and fight to have the law changed. So they're trapped and then they're at the mercy of an attorney who's supposed to be [...] there. This is an intense subject. There's the, we won't spend the whole time talking about this, Doctor Choi.
(00:20:35) Brian Choi: Don't worry.
(00:20:37) Justin McMillen: I just, I'm curious. It's interesting. And you know a lot about it.
(00:20:41) Brian Choi: So there's a flip side to that as well, where I found myself talking with family members, trying to convince the family members that the patient has the right to have these thoughts. The patient has the right to choose a life that is different than the life that you want them to have. And just because it's not what you would have chosen, that doesn't mean that I need to keep them in the hospital longer. Yes, if they stayed in the hospital longer would they benefit? Maybe. But I'm not going to take away somebody's rights to have them parked in a hospital.
(00:21:18) Justin McMillen: Oh, absolutely.
(00:21:20) Brian Choi: Because the family is saying they need to be in the hospital longer. What do you mean, you're discharging them? What do you mean, they're better enough to go? And it's not that they've necessarily hit that mark of better enough to go, but they've regained the agency to then say, I don't need to be in this level of care any longer, and I don't need my rights taken away any longer. I have the ability to make those decisions for myself, even if they are bad decisions.
(00:21:49) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:21:50) Brian Choi: And now, you know, that's mostly in the grave disability category, not when it comes down to safety. But yeah, there's, there's one side to look at it where you're keeping somebody longer, but there's the other side where people want them to stay in the hospital longer. But from the standpoint of the way that I need to hold myself responsible for that very important responsibility that I was given, I'm not going to abuse it, and I'm going to work towards getting them to the point where their agency is restored.
(00:22:22) Justin McMillen: Wow. You've had conversations like that and then go home at night and really racking your own, like...
(00:22:30) Brian Choi: Yeah, yeah. Because it's... If something bad happens, if a bad outcome happens, then that's my license on the line.
(00:22:41) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:22:43) Brian Choi: And it's not necessarily, that there's protections in place for the treating psychiatrist, that as long as you document and you show why that they do not meet the criteria anymore, then at that point you're protected, because yes, we're, we're, there's risks involved, but we're not held to the standard of reducing risk for the rest of their life.
(00:23:08) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:23:09) Brian Choi: So there's, there's things that are in place, and you have to show that you made an effort, and you can take them off the holds. And if they choose to stay in the hospital for more treatment, they can do so on a voluntary status. There's also the steps of getting them to help or getting them access or resources to help once they leave the hospital, making sure that they know who to call, making sure that they know if these things come back, if these thoughts come back, if you find yourself in this situation, that you can always come back to the hospital. So yeah, there's a responsible way to do it. But talking strictly about these holds and keeping people, there's a moment where that agency is restored, and at that point, they're able to make whatever decision that they want.
(00:23:52) Justin McMillen: Man. What about this? I think about this one a lot too, schizophrenia, you know, like, especially somebody who's got severe, I mean, they're literally in a different reality walking through the street. They're incapable of having a job. They're totally not functional, perhaps a danger to themselves. Like, how does that work? Where's the line there if somebody is...
(00:24:16) Brian Choi: Yeah. So those are usually the cases where you're on extended holds.
(00:24:22) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:24:23) Brian Choi: And those are usually the cases where we are filing the petition. It's called the Riese petition for involuntary medication.
(00:24:32) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:24:33) Brian Choi: Because whether they're unable to weigh the risks themselves, whether they're so, like you said, in a world that whatever discussion you have with them, you know, they're not, it's not making sense to them, or that their symptoms are so severe that they're constantly at risk to harming themselves or somebody else. You work, you use the system to get them the help that they need to reduce those symptoms through medications. So there's, there's this idea that all medications are bad. There's this idea, some people think that for, especially with mental health medications, they, they, there's a lot of opinions about psychiatrists and what they do. I've been called a pill pusher many times. In the hospital setting, which many psychiatrists usually only get inpatient experience during residency. So a vast majority of psychiatrists, once they're finished with training, will never do inpatient psychiatric work. It's, there's no place more evident that medications work for some of these severe mental illnesses than an inpatient setting.
(00:25:54) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(00:25:56) Brian Choi: Where you see somebody who's in full blown mania, who's not sleeping, who's grandiose, who is making connections about every little thing, and then in their minds they, they have superpowers.
(00:26:10) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:26:11) Brian Choi: Right, they, they have the cure for cancer. They have the cure for, they just need to get in front of the press, Gavin Newsom.
(00:26:20) Justin McMillen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
(00:26:22) Brian Choi: And I've been offered, you know, if you let me out, I'm going to make you so rich. Because once I get this patent or once I make this thing, I'm going to remember you, right? And there's that component of it. There's the delusional schizophrenic brain that's actively in psychosis. And you see medications work. And from the inpatient side, in a lot of these different illnesses, especially the severe ones, therapy is actually contraindicated because they're not able to reason with you on a logical level or understand what they're going through. So the treatment that we're able to provide is structure, is safety, and medications, getting the neurochemistry right.
(00:27:06) Justin McMillen: So, so can we talk about this for a second? I'm so curious because you have so much knowledge, and I know that the audience listening, there's valuable things here. So with schizophrenia, are you, you're pretty, you did a lot of work in inpatient, so schizophrenia is something you understand well. Is there, are there medications that can do anything more than just reducing the symptoms of schizophrenia? So where are we at?
(00:27:34) Brian Choi: Yeah, we have a long way to go. And that's because the medications are great at addressing what we call positive symptoms of schizophrenia.
(00:27:45) Justin McMillen: What is the positive?
(00:27:47) Brian Choi: The positive symptoms are the delusions, the, the hallucinations, the disorganization in thoughts, some of the aggression. But there's a whole other component of symptoms that we call negative symptoms. So apathy and anhedonia, the things that keep them withdrawn.
(00:28:07) Justin McMillen: The key, the positive and negative is not, sorry to interrupt you, but it's not positive like good. It's positive like charged up versus the passive, like, like kind of like external symptoms.
(00:28:18) Brian Choi: Yes. Yes.
(00:28:20) Justin McMillen: Got it. Okay.
(00:28:21) Brian Choi: So it, it's, it's, yeah. The ones that are, you're actively seeing...
(00:28:26) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:28:27) Brian Choi: Versus ones that are keeping somebody withdrawn and isolated.
(00:28:31) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:28:32) Brian Choi: So the antipsychotics, we understand the process to a certain extent about what chemical imbalance is contributing to hallucinations, what chemical imbalance, usually too much dopamine in certain parts of the brain, causing the delusions, disorganization. The antipsychotics do a good job of reducing those. Okay, but once somebody's hallucinations are addressed, that doesn't mean that they can be a functional member of society. And oftentimes you're actually, in their minds, putting them in a worse place. And this is something that you've talked about in some of your other podcasts, which is really interesting, in terms of loneliness and isolation, is the human brain would much rather be persecuted than forgotten. So these negative voices that somebody might hear are actually something that's, in their mind, beneficial. Because what's worse than that is having nobody care about you. Nobody know that you exist. So you reduce the hallucinations that might be tormenting them day and night. But now they're alone. Nobody's caring for them. Everybody else is living their lives. Nobody's paying attention. And there's just, it's just emptiness. So getting somebody to stay on the medications when... Yes, the negative, persecutory hallucinations are painful. But what's more painful than that is being nothing.
(00:30:12) Justin McMillen: Jeez.
(00:30:14) Brian Choi: So that part of it we haven't, you know, we, there's, there's really good programs out there that work with what I call primary thought disorders, which is like schizophrenia, that treat the positive symptoms with medications. And then in the community, they build them up for very simple, fulfilling tasks. Right. Something that you guys do in your treatment programs is build that community. Right. And this can be very important for this patient population because they've caused... It's so hard for family members to constantly try to motivate somebody to do something and deal with somebody who, they don't have that drive. And they don't know what to do with them anymore. Because if they, if they, all they can do is push them to take medications. And then these medications have so many side effects. But then when they're off their medications they're getting lost. They're hurting themselves, they're screaming at night. They're talking to themselves in their room. So without a knowledge of how to address that, the family members are just, they're at their wits' end. I love them, I don't know what to do for them anymore. They need to take their medications or else they get here. But then what happens after that? What's the next step for them? How do you get them to a place where they're finding connections, where they're able to find fulfillment in things that they do, and that just really doesn't exist.
(00:31:50) Justin McMillen: When you, when you said symptoms, or I mean side effects, how much of the... so you said the positive and the negative. I'm sure there's theories on, if you're not able to see the negative so much when the positive's happening, you might just have a brain that is so out of order that these two sides sort of exist. You can reduce one and the other side's there. Or it could be that the medications, in reducing the positive side, are actually producing anhedonia. What's the thought on that? Is there a theory around that?
(00:32:23) Brian Choi: So part of schizophrenia is not that you only see the positives, and then you treat the positives and the negatives come, come out.
(00:32:32) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:32:33) Brian Choi: There is a component that the negatives are there, and that you look at the negatives and the positives at the same time to make a diagnosis.
(00:32:43) Justin McMillen: Outside of medication.
(00:32:45) Brian Choi: Yes. Now, now what, what, what you're saying about the side effects is something that I'm hoping that eventually we're going to get to a place with our medications, because the, the limitations of medications right now is not necessarily the medication itself, but the delivery.
(00:33:04) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:33:05) Brian Choi: Our brain is so complex that we understand that certain parts of our brains do different things. But if you boil it down to some of the signals, the way that the brain uses to communicate and execute functions, the amount of neurotransmitters, there's not that much. But dopamine in one part of your brain will, if there's too much, you get hallucinations. So the antipsychotics block the dopamine receptor. But we can't control where that medication goes.
(00:33:38) Justin McMillen: So when you say too much, is it just too much? Is it getting up, up, took up, taken...
(00:33:44) Brian Choi: And there's, the understanding is too much dopamine is being released.
(00:33:50) Justin McMillen: Released. Okay.
(00:33:52) Brian Choi: So going a little bit into kind of the brain anatomy, your neurons are communicating with each other. You have your presynaptic neuron. You have your postsynaptic neuron. Right. The presynaptic neuron contains the vesicles, or the, the storage for the neurotransmitters. It gets released into the cleft in between the neurons, and on the postsynaptic neuron you have your receptors. Now the receptors, once the dopamine binds to the receptor and you have enough of it, then you get the downstream effects.
(00:34:25) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:34:27) Brian Choi: So in schizophrenia, in mania, there's an, there's too much dopamine in certain parts of your brain. So the antipsychotics block those receptors to reduce how much dopamine is actually firing by sitting on that receptor. But other parts of your brain need dopamine for movement and learning.
(00:34:48) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:34:50) Brian Choi: If you block, if you can only flood the brain with these dopamine receptor blockers and you can't control where they go, you're blocking the area that produces the hallucinations, but you're also blocking the area that causes movement problems.
(00:35:08) Justin McMillen: So what, tremors?
(00:35:10) Brian Choi: And yeah. So what illness is that? Parkinson's disease. So a lot of the side effects are Parkinson-like symptoms because by blocking the dopamine in the movement part of your brain, you're creating essentially a lack of dopamine.
(00:35:24) Justin McMillen: Wow.
(00:35:25) Brian Choi: So too much here. The treatment for that is blocking. But you don't get to control where it goes now. It goes over here and it's blocking it in the movement side. And now you have these side effects. So if you could control it and only get that targeted to these certain areas, then you'll have all the benefits of blocking where it's too much, and it's not going to the place where you need it in order to have appropriate movement.
(00:35:53) Justin McMillen: How much do we know? And if you don't know the answer to this, I mean, it's, I think this stuff's changing all the time, but how much do we know about what, what's actually happening in the brain? Like, is there a genetic wiring issue that's causing more dopamine to be released? Is it brain damage in some way? Like, it's certainly, I think it's, it is hereditary, right? There is a link between...
(00:36:16) Brian Choi: Yeah, there's definitely a...
(00:36:18) Justin McMillen: By the way, I'm just staying there for a minute.
(00:36:21) Brian Choi: Definitely a genetic or a familial component to it.
(00:36:24) Justin McMillen: How much of it do we actually understand?
(00:36:26) Brian Choi: I mean, yeah, there's an increased risk, which is why getting a family history is so important. But just because there's a family history doesn't mean that everybody in the family is going to have it. So why does somebody, you know, even within, amongst siblings, why does one sibling have it and the other sibling doesn't? Right. I think from the addiction side there's also that same concern. Right. What predisposes somebody to using a substance for the first or second time and then never being able to turn their brain off from it, versus somebody who might use that substance for years and then one day decide, I don't want to use it anymore, and then be able to walk away cleanly? So how much do we know about the brain? I think we're tricking ourselves to say that we know a lot, because it's so complex.
(00:37:13) Justin McMillen: It is so, and there's so many factors, right? Because it's sort of, it's constantly growing and changing based on external stimuli. And then you have genetics, and you have also, it appears like everybody's, you could have two people with the same things going on, and they have completely different behaviors, which is just like this mystery.
(00:37:31) Brian Choi: And yeah.
(00:37:32) Justin McMillen: And then hard to study because we can't cut people's brains open and look at stuff.
(00:37:39) Brian Choi: And so with, with being a physician, with being, you know, whether it's maintaining your board certification or applying for different jobs, or we have a... We need to stay on top of the newest evidence that comes out. So there's continuing education requirements. And that's because they, you know, say the stuff that you learned in medical school, by the time you're done, right, 50% of it might have already changed.
(00:38:06) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:38:07) Brian Choi: Because that's how quickly things are changing. So if you aren't staying on top of the new research, if you aren't staying on top of what's being released, then you're going to be practicing old information, and that treatment is going to not be as effective, and you might be actually doing harm at that point.
(00:38:26) Justin McMillen: Have you heard, I don't know if this is just, if this is pseudo, I don't think it's pseudoscience because I think Harvard's signing up to look at some of this stuff. But it's, it's probably not well-established science yet. But do you know anything about metabolic psychiatry? Have you heard of it?
(00:38:37) Brian Choi: Oh, yeah. Yeah.
(00:38:38) Justin McMillen: Can you explain to the audience what that is?
(00:38:40) Brian Choi: So from my understanding, what metabolic psychiatry is, is there's a, there's a link between your, well, your brain is being impacted by a lot of different health factors. And one of it is your physical health. So the metabolic issues, obesity, high cholesterol, diabetes, can impact your mental health. So there are research, and there's things that are coming out, especially with the new GLP-1 medications, how important things are for you, for your mental health, to have good physical health. There's also the connection, the, the gut-mind connection, right, where they're saying the gut microbiome is some of the biggest producers of serotonin. So that has a huge component on many different mental health illnesses.
(00:39:35) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:39:36) Brian Choi: Right. So if you can fix that component of things then you can actually address somebody's mental illness. I don't know, I don't know the specifics of the research, but they've done fecal transplants and they've gotten really good results on improving somebody's mental health without any other treatment.
(00:39:55) Justin McMillen: I've heard about this. In fact, I had a psychiatrist who came to see me, 4 or 5 years ago, and, I was, ten years ago, and she had some story that I wasn't able to confirm. So take this for what it is, but it, it's in the same vein. And she said that there was a fecal transplant done between a mother and a daughter, and it was related to obesity, or she had some sort of irritable bowel syndrome. And, but the mother also had schizophrenia or bipolar, I don't remember which one. And once the transplant was done, her symptoms subsided for like two months. It returned. But there was this period of time where the change in the gut biome appeared to have... there was correlation between the change in her symptomology, and it was like this huge... It was in the UK somewhere. I wish I could remember more about it. I tried to look it up and I felt like I must have had some of the facts wrong. So, so we're not going to say that this is a known thing, but there's definitely something to it. And what I'm interested in is there's this guy out of Harvard, and I forget his name. Maybe we could look it up and put it on the screen or something, that doctor's name. But he's doing research on the ketogenic diet and its effects on schizophrenia and bipolar one. I think maybe whether people go into mania. That's fascinating. So what's going on there?
(00:41:16) Brian Choi: You know, yeah, I would say the average American diet is so unhealthy that, you know, there's, what you put in, you're going to get out, right? If you're putting in junk, there's a good chance that junk is going to flow everywhere. And whether it's the ketogenic diet, I mean, they've done research in terms of just weight loss with all the different diets that are out there. It doesn't matter what you choose, right? Low carb, high fat, high protein, ketogenic, as long as you choose something that is healthier than what you were doing before, McDonald's, you're going to lose weight.
(00:41:58) Justin McMillen: Yes. And that's, that's the problem, right? Is so much of...
(00:42:07) Brian Choi: What you're after with this unhealthy diet is another dopamine spike. Right. The rush of salt. The rush of sweets. Right. And if you're, you're, you're conditioning yourself for that, that's what you're going to be craving.
(00:42:22) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:42:23) Brian Choi: Right. Whether it's addiction or not, I talk to some of my patients and I tell them, okay, imagine you're a caveman or a cavewoman, and you're walking around and you're trying to forage and find your food. The sweetest thing that you'll ever find is going to be fruits or something. Right now, imagine that from 2026 I invent a time machine. And do you have a favorite candy?
(00:42:50) Justin McMillen: Oh, maybe Twizzlers.
(00:42:53) Brian Choi: Twizzlers. Okay, so I, I take a bag of Twizzlers, and I put it in the time machine, and I ship it to you, caveman Justin. And you're walking around and you find this bag of Twizzlers and you're confused what it is. But then eventually you put it in your mouth to taste it. And the level of sweetness from a Twizzlers versus any fruit is going to be exponentially higher. Now you gobble up the whole bag of Twizzlers. Now what is the goal for the rest of your life?
(00:43:27) Justin McMillen: To find more.
(00:43:29) Brian Choi: Find more of those Twizzlers.
(00:43:31) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(00:43:32) Brian Choi: Right. So now we're in this day and age where it's not just exponential dopamine hits. It's how fast can we get those exponential dopamine hits?
(00:43:41) Justin McMillen: Oh, man. You're right. You're speaking my language right now. This is with doom scrolling, right? I've heard things, now it's probably going to get less and less, if your short or your reel... Doesn't have their attention in 1 to 3 seconds. Luke, what is it? 1 to 3?
(00:43:56) Brian Choi: Yeah.
(00:43:57) Justin McMillen: He knows. Yeah. You're on to the next one. We have some reels that have a million views, and it's because of that, they grab you, you know, right out the gate. That's... man, this is an interesting subject. It's, you know, this is where the gut-brain axis sort of comes into play. Because of course, our dopaminergic system, which causes drive, is going to be tied to our survival and food. If we eat high calorie food or high glycemic food like fruits, we're going to go, the brain needs to activate so we know more of this. This will allow me to get fat so I can make it through famine. It makes complete sense that we're all chasing these pleasures, especially with food. But then also anything that activates that system that says, you know, yes, you won. Yes, you won. Yes, you won. Because winning is surviving. What do we do about that? How about, let me ask the question a different way. What do we do about the fact that we are built for a completely different time than the one that we live in, and that our entire environment around us is set up in a way that is only going to promote us continuing to engage in indulgence and, and more? How do we contend with that?
(00:45:20) Brian Choi: The, the framework that I'll, I'll present to sort of address this is getting somebody their agency back.
(00:45:30) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:45:32) Brian Choi: Now what do I mean? It means that I want somebody to feel like they have the ability to change, or be, be the one that their actions will impact the outcome. Right? Instead of feeling like there's nothing I can do. This is, if I was only born when McDonald's wasn't around, I wouldn't have this problem. But you aren't. You're born now, right? This is the life that you were given. And you have to be in a place to say, I can make the change. I am not going to doom scroll anymore. I am not going to eat fast food anymore. I am going to be able to change, and my behaviors can contribute to that. So they have to have that sense of agency come back. So this kind of applies to a lot of different areas. But one of the analogies that I use for my patients is... I tell my patients sometimes that, you know, I ask them, okay, in the situation that you're in right now, what do you think is your brain's goal? And a lot of times they'll say, you know, it's there to help me. It's there to help me achieve happiness, for me to achieve my goals. And I tell them no.
(00:47:01) Justin McMillen: It'd be nice.
(00:47:04) Brian Choi: Yeah, it'd be nice. And we can get there. But your brain's goal is actually efficiency. It wants to take the same things that you've been doing and make it as efficient as possible. Right. That's where conditioning comes from, right? Most people know the Pavlov experiment, right? You ring a bell, you show a dog food, the dog salivates. After you keep doing this, right, you don't even have to show the dog food anymore, because the brain has turned that into an efficient process. Every time I hear the bell, I see food. I'm going to get ready to eat and I'm going to salivate. Soon enough, you take out the food, bell, the dog starts to salivate. So we're, we're, by what we're choosing to do on a daily basis, the brain is programming efficiency. Now, most of the time what this leads to is your brain being in control. Not because it's got its own set of motives, but it's programmed to become efficient. So that efficiency can either be something that you choose to help you, or it can be set up so that it's only hurting you. And most of the time, that efficiency allows your brain, another car analogy, to be in the driver's seat, and for you not to be in the passenger seat, not to be in the back seat, not to be in the trunk. But now you're ten feet behind the car, being dragged by your ankles on a rope that's attached to the car, because the brain is going where it efficiently knows to go. So to get somebody their agency back, so they can say, okay, now instead of just being dragged along, I can make decisions that will impact my future. I can say no to McDonald's, I can say no to candy, and I can keep making these right decisions to get to the place where now I'm making healthy choices, right? But it's reprogramming to get it to a place where you're choosing the outcome, versus your brain taking a process that you didn't think about and then turning that into your autopilot.
(00:49:24) Justin McMillen: Is this like the, is it the same as default mode network? I, I've heard that, sounds, sounds like it would describe the same thing. That's a, so it's so interesting the way, the way you said that. I love it, because you said brain. You didn't say mind. Right. So you're talking about the actual, this, this system, this chemistry system, or system of meat and chemicals. Right. And so that's driving. I like the, the, the visual that you painted of being dragged behind, it's so true. And then to think that we all engage in these things every day, different behaviors, and that because the brain wants to be efficient, it's going to continue to sort of shape around that. And then you could potentially fill your entire day with automation. And then suddenly, through some sort of moment of conscious observation of your life, you're like, I don't like who I am. And you go see Doctor Choi and he's like, we got to get you agency, right? We got to get you back in the driver's seat. So when, when it comes to this efficiency thing, how much of it is the brain... So efficiency, let's unpack that. Is it the brain's trying to find the path of least resistance to preserve energy? Is that what you mean by efficiency?
(00:50:37) Brian Choi: Okay. Another way to put it is the brain is lazy.
(00:50:40) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(00:50:42) Brian Choi: And it doesn't want to use energy where it doesn't have to. Which is why change is so hard. Because change requires a lot of energy. A reflex is no thought required, no energy required, right? The reflexes that we have built into our nervous system. Right. The one, you hit your knee and your leg goes out. That's a reflex loop for nerves that don't even have to go up to the brain. Right. So it's, it wants to reduce the amount of energy that is required to do the same behavior.
(00:51:15) Justin McMillen: That makes sense. It makes sense too, because I like, I think of things through an evolutionary lens quite a bit. And you know, of course, all things, I mean, energy is interesting. You can go down to like a physics level. It's like you want to conserve it at every level. And if life is always trying to stay alive, right, life wants to, you know, continue to move forward. It's going to do everything in its power to preserve energy. And then that can tie into all kinds of things, like not moving, eating as much as possible, moving the least amount possible. You can put it into the brain and say the brain is taking the path of least resistance, like water or electricity, or, you know, what's going to have the least resistance. So it appears to be almost like a larger law of things. We can make it pejorative and say lazy, but really, it's not even lazy. It's just the nature of things.
(00:52:04) Brian Choi: Yeah, and it's not that it's broken. It's actually doing what it was designed to do. So that's the difference between somebody coming and saying, I need, my brain needs to be fixed, versus my brain just needs to be reprogrammed. The programming that it decided didn't really have my conscious inputs. It chose what it turned into its autopilot. That wasn't necessarily helpful for me.
(00:52:26) Justin McMillen: Is this how you think of all the people that come into your...
(00:52:29) Brian Choi: For a lot of them, yes.
(00:52:31) Justin McMillen: And you have your own practice, for people that are listening. And you, you work in Orange County?
(00:52:37) Brian Choi: Yes, I work in Orange County, but I do, I see patients virtually. So anybody in California.
(00:52:42) Justin McMillen: Anyone in California. That's amazing. Do you, do you have your own practice, or do you, do you have psychiatrists that work with you?
(00:52:49) Brian Choi: It's just me.
(00:52:51) Justin McMillen: Really? Oh my gosh, you need to, I mean, you know, you do what you want, but the way you're looking at things, it would be very amazing for you to have people that you're training, and you're taking some of these things and really running with them.
(00:53:03) Brian Choi: Yeah. That's, that's, you know, I've thought about that. And that's sort of something that I may be working towards, because I do miss that team aspect of things. But, you know, this is, I, I started my practice, it's been a little less than two years.
(00:53:17) Justin McMillen: Okay. So it's new. So you came out of the hospital?
(00:53:21) Brian Choi: Hospital, yes.
(00:53:22) Justin McMillen: Into this, because, and you were running a huge hospital down south. I mean, I'm familiar with it.
(00:53:28) Brian Choi: Yeah. So it was one of the few. I mean, inpatient psych units are becoming fewer and fewer because they don't make money, so they're becoming more and more rare.
(00:53:36) Justin McMillen: That should scare everyone.
(00:53:38) Brian Choi: Yes.
(00:53:39) Justin McMillen: And we already see people walking around on the street talking to themselves and going to the bathroom in the corners, like it's... I mean, we need, we need more. We need more.
(00:53:49) Brian Choi: The problem is they're moving the other direction, and...
(00:53:54) Justin McMillen: The... but under your practice...
(00:53:57) Brian Choi: Well, that, the difficulties and the, the struggles that I experienced from the inpatient side helped shape what I wanted to create for the outpatient side. And a lot of that was, okay, I get somebody, my goal from the hospital side was to get them just functional enough to leave the hospital, because that's as much as the insurance company is going to pay for. As soon as they cross that imaginary line, which is very low, they need to leave, and I need to hand them off to the outpatient side. And for a lot of the patients that kept coming back to the hospital, I would ask them, who is your outpatient provider? Or, you went to therapy? What are they doing to help you with these issues? And a lot of times it's, I barely see them. Right. I see them for seven minutes. Right. And sometimes before I'm even done talking they're pushing a pill across their desk, a sample that they got that's lining their, their desk. And that's what I'm going for. And I don't have enough time to actually tell them what's going on before they're telling me what pill I need to take or what dose I need to increase. And by that time it's, you know, you're seeing, there's, you know, when I'm reviewing, when I was reviewing charts for new patients, I could look at somebody's medication list and I would ask, who's, who's doing this to you? Right. They're on so many different medications. One medication is causing a side effect, so they're on another medication to treat that side effect. Then that medication's causing a side effect. So it's this never ending cycle. They're on three antidepressants at ineffective doses. And it's because every time something bad happens, you're not getting to the root of the problem. You just say, I don't feel good. So what's, what's somebody going to do in seven minutes? What's somebody going to do in 15 minutes? So because of that, I said, okay, that's not how I'm going to do things. I want to really get to know the person. I want to say, hey, let's look at how your brain works. Let's understand what's actually going on. If there are things that are happening that medications can help you with, absolutely. We're going to use them because they're a tool. But the goal is to get you to the place where your symptoms are not only reduced, but you're thriving and you're achieving the, the goals that you want to achieve. Not just, I don't want to be sick anymore.
(00:56:35) Justin McMillen: Absolutely. Use the cough button. Excuse me. That's a, it's a serious issue in this country. The, the seven minute appointments and the... we have people come to us on 20 medications. One of the things that Tree House specializes in is helping people come off of all medications and then getting a baseline in order to establish which medications that they need to be on. And, it's really sad to me, because there's not a lot of places that are even capable of doing that, you know. And this isn't a Tree House promotional idea, but like, without addressing the chemistry, you're really fighting against yourself. But in order to do that, you have to have a system to do it. So like, we have guys waking up, we get them up at 5:00 in the morning. They're here at six. They're in a team. The team's cultural, there's a culture to each team, so they're interacting with each other. There's a lot of, the community is supporting. And some of you talked about with schizophrenia, and, then not schizophrenia, but treating the... The negative side of schizophrenia, and the need for that system.
(00:57:47) Brian Choi: Yeah.
(00:57:48) Justin McMillen: But yeah, finding a place that does that is really challenging. And so you have people on these, they're trapped. They're trapped on 10, 15... I mean, we had one time, we had a guy that came in, he bounced around the foster system when he was younger. And when he showed up here, he was on, I think it was just under, maybe 19 medications. And he'd been on meds since he was not even ten years old. He'd always been on meds. He had no idea what he was like. He had so many different diagnoses. I mean, we were pulling all of his biopsychosocial, all of his documents from other places, and it was like every diagnosis you could think of. It was ridiculous. It couldn't be all of that.
(00:58:26) Brian Choi: Right.
(00:58:27) Justin McMillen: And there's no way you could diagnose someone responsibly with him being on so many different medications. The symptoms are just all over the place. That has to be infuriating to see. So this, this motivated you? Was it part of you leaving, or was it just, when you left, you decided this is how I'm going to do this differently?
(00:58:42) Brian Choi: Well, it, looking back at my career, looking back at my training, one of the things that I heard while I was a resident, by one of my attendings, was, it was, it was a, at that point, it was a criticism. It was, you are not using medications enough. And I had to wrestle with that at the time. But now that I look back, I don't see it as a criticism anymore. I see it as my approach that can help in areas that need to be addressed, that medications might not always be the best tool. Can they be used? Yes. But is too many medications a problem? Absolutely. So even on the hospital side, I would spend some time, when they're coming to the hospital... It's because things have gotten so bad. And oftentimes I would look at their med list and say, okay, we need to clean this up. We have the ability to control and to put you in a safe place, similar to kind of what you talked about with Tree House. It's, the environment can be so helpful when we're controlling, when we have eyes... 24/7. We know how long they're sleeping. We know what they're eating. We know how they're interacting with other people. We see multiple points of interactions with different levels of providers, how they're interacting with their peers and other patients, how they're interacting with people who come and visit them. So we have all this information, and then we can really get, like you said, a good baseline. And sometimes you're doing addition by subtraction.
(01:00:28) Justin McMillen: Yeah. Titration. Absolutely. Love it.
(01:00:31) Brian Choi: You take them off of meds and they're like, why did somebody think I needed to be on more meds when I feel so much better on less meds? But it takes time. It takes the ability to say, okay, let's try something else. Let's not just listen to this, that things are getting worse, but let's go deeper. Let's figure out why it's getting worse.
(01:00:54) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:00:55) Brian Choi: Are you saying that you're more depressed because things have actually gotten worse? Or is it because you got a ticket on the way over here, and then you had to wait an hour in the waiting room, and you show up already mad, and I can see that you're mad, but it's not because everything else, maybe everything else was great for the last month, but it's what happened before you showed up. And then now you're feeling horrible. And because I have such little time, I'm going to increase your meds.
(01:01:22) Justin McMillen: That's crazy. That's... here's another, I'm curious about this, too. It seems like some psychiatric illnesses, or mental illnesses, are so clearly chemical in nature. Like you, like you see somebody who has bipolar one, and it's like they haven't slept in three days and it's, it's like they're on drugs, but they're not, right? Or schizophrenia, and they're delusional, they're hearing, they're psychotic. And then maybe there's some other ones, probably bipolar two, serious depression, that one doesn't seem as... I don't know, I'm not a doctor. What I'm getting at is, it appears like there's a pool of psychiatric, psychiatric illness, or mental illness, either...
(01:02:02) Brian Choi: Oh, okay.
(01:02:04) Justin McMillen: There's a pool that is, like, very clearly chemical. And then there's another pool that could be chemical, it could be life conditions, life circumstances, but is also treated with chemistry. How do, how does a psychiatrist think about that? How do you think about that?
(01:02:25) Brian Choi: There is a, I'm going to call it an elementary level of understanding, even on the, the chemical side of things. Theoretically, yes, for mania in bipolar one, there's too much dopamine, because we know that dopamine in certain areas causes these symptoms. There could be too much norepinephrine, another stimulating neurotransmitter, that may be contributing to your elevated heart rate and your inability to sleep and not feel tired. Right. But how much? If it is in excess, we don't know why is it in excess. We don't know what caused that part of the brain to start unloading all of the dopamine. We don't know. So yes, there, it helps you think about how to treat things from the standpoint of, okay, too much here, I have this tool that can address how much is here. So to address what I think is going on here, let's use this medication. But that's only one component of things. What about everything else that's going on? What about your home situation? What about, what are you doing for your physical health? To just look at it as a chemical imbalance, you're, you're turning a very complex issue that deals with mood, that deals with biology, that deals with neurotransmitters, that deals with so many different components of things that we understand and some that we don't... And you're narrowing it down to balance.
(01:04:05) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:04:06) Brian Choi: Here's the problem. Here's too much. How do we fix too much?
(01:04:10) Justin McMillen: Sure. Sure. I think the way I'm thinking of it is like, are there some psychiatric illnesses that just cannot be, you cannot live with? I mean, you could, but life would be unbearable without medication.
(01:04:21) Brian Choi: Oh, yeah.
(01:04:22) Justin McMillen: And, and then so those, you could argue that that's just, definitely there's chemistry at play. Like there is no non-chemical way for these to... I mean, I've heard stories. In fact, somebody you mentioned, Doctor DeLuise, he's got a pretty interesting case study that you've got to ask him about, if you ever get a chance to talk to him, about a person who had been hospitalized for several years with schizophrenia, that he ended up, the family had the resources to do it, and they hired him. And the guy is now medication free. He's a self-supporting artist. And he's not institutionalized. He takes care of himself. He's, he's out there, meaning he's got a lot of thoughts and things. But somehow DeLuise managed to figure out how to make sense of his thinking, and then taught him a frame for how to think about his thinking. And I mean, again, it's like probably all these patients you saw at Mission, you thought to yourself, man, if I had them for like a month and a lot of time, I could do so much good. But you're not, we're not in that position. You have to have these weird moments where you had, the family's got the right resources, you find the right person, and somebody really takes the time to care. And I imagine you in the hospital seeing patients and having the insurance dictate who's there, and knowing that you could help them, especially with the ideas that you're implementing now, that had to have been incredibly difficult for you.
(01:05:47) Brian Choi: Oh, yeah. Yeah. And part of, you know, there's so many frustrating aspects of working with insurance companies, and any doctor that has ever worked with an insurance company will... Will have stories about this. Right. And they can go on and on. But to have somebody on the other line of a phone call who is not an MD, I don't know their qualifications, but they're looking at a screen, probably with prompts on what they need to do, maybe even a quota of how many denials that they need to give, and for them to dictate the care that we're giving when we're in the front lines, and, you know, explaining until I'm blue in the face why what they're suggesting won't work, or why we've actually already tried that. If you would just read the notes that you require us to send you.
(01:06:41) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:06:42) Brian Choi: So the, the way that I've described it is, a lot of times insurance, and I can't think of any other industry, but they benefit from their own built-in inefficiencies.
(01:06:53) Justin McMillen: Yeah. Because it's... very perfectly said.
(01:06:56) Brian Choi: If they can make you so frustrated that you hang up the phone, or they put you on hold so many times that you end up having to walk away to take care of another patient, and you don't go through that review... They can just deny you. So by making it difficult, they actually benefit.
(01:07:14) Justin McMillen: Do you think that they sit around and think about this? How do you think that that... what would you, like, what would, what would the person say that's arguing with you at Mission, and they're on the other side looking at these prompts? Certainly these... I mean, I genuinely believe people are good. Do you think that person goes home at night and is like, I screwed seven doctors today? Like, how do you think they think about it? Yeah, I know that's a hard question.
(01:07:41) Brian Choi: It's a hard question.
(01:07:43) Justin McMillen: On the front lines and dealt with it. Yeah. Difficult shoes to put yourself in.
(01:07:48) Brian Choi: I think some people will view that as just a job. Their boss is telling them, their manager is telling them what they need to do, and that they need to stick to the script, and the people that are doing that, they may be okay saying, okay, this is what I'm supposed to do. I don't have to think about it. I'm just going to go along with what I'm told to do. And at the end of the day, I'm getting paid and I am putting food on the table for my family. And that's a lot of jobs, right?
(01:08:18) Justin McMillen: Yeah. That is a lot of jobs.
(01:08:21) Brian Choi: And, and for some people that's enough. And the system was developed to cause that, not them. Right. So I don't necessarily vilify the person that I'm talking to on the phone. It's the, the insurance company that, you know, they're, they're more, they, they worry more about their shareholders than the members who hold that insurance. And, you know, the frustration boils to the point where we had that incident, right, earlier this year with the UnitedHealthcare...
(01:08:52) Justin McMillen: Yeah. Yeah.
(01:08:53) Brian Choi: So, you know, the frustrations are boiling over.
(01:08:57) Justin McMillen: Yeah. With the, the UnitedHealthcare... What was the guy's name? Man...
(01:09:03) Brian Choi: Yeah, yeah, yeah, man...
(01:09:05) Justin McMillen: Mangione killed the CEO of UnitedHealthcare. Shot him in cold blood. And then, were you surprised at the public's response to that?
(01:09:13) Brian Choi: No, no.
(01:09:14) Justin McMillen: What was the public's response there?
(01:09:16) Brian Choi: I mean, there's both sides, right? There's no way that you can deny that that was not the right thing to do. But then you're going to find the same, another group of people who are justifying those actions. And it's really hard to know the inner workings of insurance and then to not be able to see that side. Right. Because there's, there's conflict there for me too. Right? There's, it's so frustrating. And there's been so many times where everybody is frustrated, the family is frustrated, the care team is frustrated, the patient is frustrated. But there's nothing you can do except work in this system.
(01:09:55) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:09:57) Brian Choi: Which is one of the reasons why I left that system. And I, I don't take insurance for that reason. And yes, does that limit the people who can see me? Yes. But it also allows me to practice the way that I need to practice to give my patients the best.
(01:10:13) Justin McMillen: You know what I'd love to do? I don't know that I have the bandwidth for it, Doctor Choi, but I would love to take guys, doctors that are working like you are. And so one of my visions is, I've got a foundation, and I, the idea would be to set up a team of world class, like top in the world at negotiating contracts, setting up payment models and things, and then bringing something that only would be accessible to, like, the biggest hospital groups to a guy like you, and saying, like, you're not going to have to pay for this, but I'm going to put these people around you and they're going to set you up with the payers in a way to where you do pilot programs or specialized models where you can do what you want to do, and show the public what you're capable of, and how ultimately it will save the insurance company money and benefit the patient. That's, it kills me to think about this, because we're similar. We're out of network, actually. Nowadays we have some of our, we have contracts now, but we've ran a PPO, you know, sort of approach, out of network provider for years. And so we have a lot of cash pay. We treat a lot of people for free. Or, you know, outside of the, we do what we have to do. But I'm obsessed with how can we figure out other ways to pay the bill, because the third party payers are not doing their job, and because work like that you offer should be accessible to more people. Bottom line, it's like, it shouldn't, people should not be limited by having the dollars to pay, you know? We need more people that are doing what you're doing. Going back to the, I don't want to talk about Mangione anymore, but that one was very interesting, I guess I will, but that one was very interesting for me, because I'm a pretty compassionate man, and I had to really, like, I was so cold to it that I had to take time to read about who he was as a person, because I felt really shitty about how I was responding to it, because I was like, I literally didn't care. And that's, that's not me. Anybody who knows me knows that's not how I work. And I had to, like, read about him, to humanize him, to not, because I saw that moment as like, this is an example of, this is truly like all one moment representing the, the pain of so many hospital rooms, so many doctors, so many families that have gone bankrupt, all in one moment. This one action, which is exactly what he wanted. And the last thing we want is criminals being put in that position. So it was like my head was just messed up. But I spent time learning about him and was like, he's a human, and this is terrible. And I had to, like, really work. And I hope this isn't too much for me to say on the show. I don't know, but that, that's just me being honest. I could talk to you for hours. So, I mean, you're a super fascinating person, but I want to get into... Sorry, I'm just looking at what he has here. I want to talk, I just want to talk about your work and some of this stuff and how you're... so you opened a practice two years ago?
(01:13:20) Brian Choi: Yes.
(01:13:21) Justin McMillen: And you are, you're cash pay only, so you don't have to be constrained by the large payers. And what is your, what, what do you specialize in?
(01:13:29) Brian Choi: So my... My, my practice is called Better Choices. So I, on the inpatient side, I didn't get to choose who came to the hospital. So I would treat everything. Suicidality, depression, anxiety, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, personality disorders, substance use, addiction. I've treated it all. Now, what does that mean in terms of what I treat now? I have the ability to treat everything, but the people that tend to, the patients that tend to come to me are ones that are struggling with things that may not fit cleanly into a diagnosis. They know they're not performing the way that they want to perform, or that they've performed previously. Could it be a mood issue? Could it be anxiety? Could it be trauma? All the above. So more so than saying I treat generalized anxiety disorder, I treat major depressive disorder, I treat bipolar disorder, yes, I have patients who have those diagnoses. But what I want to do with my patients is help them understand themselves, help them get to the place where they know why they're not performing the way that they want to perform, and then helping them get to a place where they're not only doing better, but they're achieving goals. They're thriving. They're able to say, okay, I was, even before I came to you, this is where I was. Now I'm so much better. I wanted to achieve this, and that wasn't even possible. But because we minimized, because we addressed symptoms, because we looked in areas that nobody else has looked at or didn't tie that together, because we're addressing sleep, because we're addressing diet, because we're addressing exercise, because we're addressing spirituality, because we're addressing relationships, I can say now that I'm doing great, I'm thriving. This is the person that I want to be. So that's what I'm hoping all of my patients are able to say.
(01:15:44) Justin McMillen: So what's the, what would you say is the biggest... I think I know the answer to this, but I think giving you a chance to sort of map this out. What's the biggest difference between what you're doing and what most psychiatrists do?
(01:15:58) Brian Choi: What we were, what training taught me in residency was to ask somebody, what are your symptoms? How long have you been having them? What's your family history? So for bipolar disorder, for major depressive disorder, for generalized anxiety disorder, there is criteria, as determined by psychiatrists, from the DSM, so that we are all on the same page when it comes to the diagnoses that we're talking about. So when I say somebody has major depressive disorder, a psychiatrist in New York will agree, because we're on the same page. The criteria is there, right. If everybody had their own definition of what major depressive disorder was, who knows?
(01:16:47) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(01:16:48) Brian Choi: Right. We would never be able to talk about things uniformly. So training teaches us to see if they fit the criteria for these illnesses, to give them a diagnosis, and then to prescribe them a medication to help them with that. Oftentimes with my patients, I, they don't have a diagnosis because they don't fit cleanly into this strict criteria. And oftentimes they don't want medications. And because I don't have to send my notes to an insurance company... and in order for an insurance company to reimburse, there has to be a diagnosis. If your bill doesn't have a diagnosis, they'll reject it. So they need that. And they use a lot of different, you know, the ICD-10, which is not, was never designed for clinical medicine. It was more designed for research. But it gets very clunky. But that is not what's important to me. What's important to me is helping somebody understand themselves, figure out where their issues are, and then ask them what their goals are, and then work together to achieve those goals.
(01:18:08) Justin McMillen: That's great. That's, so you don't... so if somebody wants to see a psychiatrist, or somebody that has your background and your understanding, and you've been in the trenches and you've done all this stuff, and they don't, they're not comfortable with labels, and they don't want somebody pushing medications on them, you're kind of the perfect fit doctor to come see, because you're not going to try to put them in a box, because you don't need to.
(01:18:32) Brian Choi: Yeah, the box doesn't help me. The box doesn't help you. And by you coming to me, you might already be in a box.
(01:18:39) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:18:40) Brian Choi: And we need to get you out of the box so that you can get better. But the idea is, being in the hospital has allowed me to become very good at knowing what medications can do.
(01:18:52) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(01:18:53) Brian Choi: Where they produce side effects, what type of discussion you need to have about medications to feel comfortable taking them. And I'm not going to shy away from recommending a medication if I feel that it's beneficial. But that doesn't mean that once we get you better that I'm just going to say you got to keep taking it if you get better. And a lot of my patients have gotten better. We take them off medications. But that is not where the work stops. The work doesn't stop when you're feeling better. It doesn't stop when your anxiety is controlled or that your mood is better, you're no longer depressed, right? We call, we sort of talk about it the same way we talk about cancer. When your depressive symptoms are in remission, right now, even in diagnosis, you're major depressive disorder in partial remission, in full remission. Right. But that doesn't say anything about the quality of your life. It just means that the, again, we'll talk about the negative parts of the diagnosis, are no longer there. But that doesn't mean now you're happy. Right? That doesn't mean now you're achieving goals, that things have improved. It just means that, you, maybe you're sleeping better. You're able to enjoy things. Right. The inappropriate mood that we're using as a diagnosis has now become appropriate, but that doesn't mean you're thriving. So once the symptoms are addressed, then I tell my patients, this is where the fun work starts. Now we can start moving you towards the goals and the life that you want, because the symptoms were preventing you from getting there.
(01:20:34) Justin McMillen: It's like you're almost like a, don't want to minimize you down to this, but it's like a coach in a way, because you're, you're... I think in this country we're so obsessed with just not sick that nobody thinks about thriving and, and being well. And so it sounds like a lot of your work, my understanding is, step one is, let's get this person, understand them. So you have to understand them, understand themselves. Is medication appropriate here? There? Maybe it is. Maybe it's not. Symptom reduction doesn't mean better. Better doesn't even mean better. The question is, where do you want to be?
(01:21:10) Brian Choi: Yeah, yeah. And I've had a lot of patients who in the hospital would come to me and say, my life coach told me this, and nothing against life coaches. But like you said, I'm like a coach, but I'm a coach with an MD.
(01:21:28) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:21:30) Brian Choi: So, you know, I, I know my training has allowed me to see a different perspective and have a different set of tools that a regular life coach might not have. And whether we use those tools or not is not important, as much as, if we need those tools, wouldn't you want somebody who has the access to them and knows how to use them, versus somebody who, they're not even thinking about those tools?
(01:21:58) Justin McMillen: Of course. I mean, you, I mean, also your life experience. I mean, you've got an MD and MBA, Master of Arts in hospital administration, medical sciences...
(01:22:09) Brian Choi: Medical science.
(01:22:11) Justin McMillen: Excuse me. That just, the, the, the amount of education you've had. I mean, you were... I think this is important because there's a lot of coaches on the internet, and some of them are really good. And I don't know that, I don't believe every one of them has to be a doctor. I'm not saying that. But I also think that, a guy like you comes along and we need to take you seriously because you have the education, you have the background. It's not just what you know. It's the fact that you did all of that. That was years and years of time and energy spent focused on, this is what I'm aiming for, in a very difficult environment. You accomplished that, and then you've worked on the front lines, you've paid your dues, you've done all these things. You understand the system. You chose to work in the system in a different way, and now you're coming out of the gate with an approach to truly addressing mental health, not just putting Band-Aids on it or masking symptoms. So if you're going to spend, you know, $600 an hour or $700 an hour with some life coach, which people do, it's far better... I don't know what your rates are, but it's far better to spend it on somebody who actually has the medical degree and the license.
(01:23:18) Brian Choi: Yeah, yeah. And something that I'll add to that is, psychiatry wasn't something that was even on my mind. I told you I come from a family of doctors, so, I don't have a psychiatrist in my family. OB-GYN, pediatrician, nephrologist, colorectal surgeon, and two OB-GYNs, ER physician. So...
(01:23:37) Justin McMillen: Wow. A lot of different... you guys are all underachievers.
(01:23:41) Brian Choi: Yeah. I've told people that, you know, get them, get us all together, we could open up our own hospital.
(01:23:48) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:23:49) Brian Choi: But no psychiatrist. And my path was actually going to take me towards anesthesia.
(01:23:55) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(01:23:56) Brian Choi: And then in medical school, I actually got super depressed, and I lost agency. And I finally got to the place where my goals were being achieved. I wanted to be a doctor my whole life, even with my family members telling me, are you sure? Like, this is not, this is, you know, you need to be sure that this is what you want to do, because it's not an easy path. And it was all I wanted to do. And when I finally got into medical school, I was so happy. And now I'm in medical school doing it, and now there's no hope. I'm waking up feeling horrible. I had thoughts about, it would be better if I just disappeared. I remember sitting in different cafes, studying, and looking at people walking past me and thinking, I want to be them, because they could smile. It was anybody that was laughing, walking by me, I just wanted to be them, because I felt so empty inside, even though on paper it made no sense. I had everything that I wanted. Nothing was, nothing happened to me that I should have been depressed about. I was where I needed to be. I was achieving well. My friends would look at me and my family would look at me and they would not know what was going on. But internally, I lost the ability to feel and to have hope in an appropriate way. So I, I took, in between, I did a combined MD MBA program, so I took the year between my third and fourth year of medical school to go to business school. And it was a very different change of pace. And it was during that time that I did a SWOT analysis. Are you familiar?
(01:25:51) Justin McMillen: Weakness, yeah, opportunities. I'm an entrepreneur.
(01:25:55) Brian Choi: Yeah, so very important. I did that to myself. And I thought, all my strengths... Don't align with anesthesia. This path that I thought I was going down, this, it's not what this analysis is telling me. What do I enjoy doing? I loved connecting with patients. As a medical student, did I enjoy procedures? No. I actually didn't like the, the culture of the OR. And I remember very vividly walking into the OR as a medical student, and the circulating OR nurse came through, and she said, everybody needs to be on their best behavior because surgeon so-and-so is having a bad day. And I thought, why? Why does he get to dictate how everybody else's day is going? And I was like, that's not the environment that I want to be in. So then I was like, why am I choosing anesthesia? And a lot of it was for the wrong reasons, financial reasons.
(01:26:56) Justin McMillen: There's a lot of clout too.
(01:26:58) Brian Choi: Yeah.
(01:27:00) Justin McMillen: For the title.
(01:27:01) Brian Choi: Yeah. Like, yeah.
(01:27:03) Justin McMillen: In every room they're central. It's like this.
(01:27:06) Brian Choi: Yeah. It's a powerful... and as medical students, my, my friend group, we would look at psychiatrists and be like, oh, that's not real medicine, right. That's, that's hokey pokey feeling stuff, right? You, you aren't really doing anything. You don't have evidence to back up what you guys are... You're just talking about feelings. So it wasn't until I took that step back, went through my own depression, went through my own analysis, and I came back from a standpoint of going from a place where I didn't have agency, I didn't have hope, to then regaining that, was the strongest motivator for me to say, I want to help people who were in similar situations that I was, because when you don't have hope and then you get to a place where hope is back, you feel like a superhuman. Right. And maybe similar to your experience with addiction, when you feel like there's something that is in control, and then you gain control over that, you, you're able to do things that you previously thought were impossible.
(01:28:13) Justin McMillen: Yeah, absolutely. I think that's so interesting, that when you, when I meet people who work in healthcare that have gone through their own things, it's the depth of the, the energy behind your work is just, it's extraordinary. And that's what I mean. You just painted... in fact, I wrote down here, start with personal story at the beginning, Luke. So you have a little bit of flipping around to do, but I think you starting with that would be really nice. He's going to kill me, like, declaring all these edits. We don't edit very often. He's smiling back there. Everybody knows Luke off camera. They don't know, he's gonna one day come out and show himself. Yeah. I mean, it's, it's, you know, I don't know what your personal beliefs are, but sometimes it seems like there's something greater than us, or some sort of power that comes out and just sets things straight, and it's like you ended up having one moment that changed everything in terms of how you were moving forward. And then now look at you, you chose a field of medicine that you would never have chosen otherwise. It became incredibly personal for you. It's sort of perfect.
(01:29:22) Brian Choi: Oh, yeah, I couldn't, you're, you're absolutely right. I tell people that, it's not, I don't feel like I chose psychiatry. It's like psychiatry chose me. And it just fits in so well with how my brain works and processes things. So when I'm sitting across from a patient that comes to me and they're telling me about what's been going on, these things that I'm able to kind of think about, and the way that I want to move forward with them and get them to... it's not like I, like you asked me, is there a name for that? Is there... There isn't, but it's just my brain is thinking about, okay, here's a process. What is causing this person to feel like they don't have control over it anymore? And how do we get them to the place where they understand it enough, where we can start making small wins for them to gain control, move them from behind the car, being dragged, to the trunk, then to the back seat, then to the passenger seat, and now they're in the driver's seat. And then from there they get to choose where they want to go.
(01:30:27) Justin McMillen: Are you, are you in the car with them for a lot of it?
(01:30:31) Brian Choi: I mean, I do, I see, [...] a lot of my patients have told me, you're different because you actually talk to me, versus just ask me questions and let me talk. And I feel like there's a place for that. But initially they need that extra help. So I want to be the one that is, that is helping them up, or be the one to tell them, hey, being dragged is not comfortable, right? I know you feel comfortable back there because you've been there for so long, but the view is way better up front, and it's so much more fun driving than just being a passenger. So being able to help them see that. But then it's the thing that I see, is people try before they come to a psychiatrist. It's not usually the first thing that they want to do. First trouble I experience, I need to go see a psychiatrist. It's usually, okay, I've tried, I've tried, and it hasn't worked. And now I feel like there is no hope, because everything that I've tried has failed. And then I need to come and hold their hands and be with them and say, no, you haven't tried this, and you haven't stuck with it long enough for there to be results. And let's learn from what hasn't worked. Why didn't this work? Oh, it's because you weren't, you didn't understand it enough. You jumped into the action phase, which is what most people do, but didn't spend enough time in the understanding, research phase to come up with the right plan. So let's back up. Let's spend more time in the understanding phase. Let's spend more time in the research phase. And then we'll come up with a plan, and we'll do it together.
(01:32:09) Justin McMillen: So you're spending months developing a treatment plan, because you're doing it with them...
(01:32:14) Brian Choi: Well...
(01:32:15) Justin McMillen: Which is what we're supposed to do, by the way.
(01:32:18) Brian Choi: It's evolving. So our treatment plan starts from the first time that I meet them. Because if I'm going to say, okay, you just spent an hour with me and we learned this stuff, but we're not going to make any changes, we're going to wait until we meet ten more times before we start implementing... No, we need to get the low hanging fruit.
(01:32:37) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(01:32:38) Brian Choi: There are so many things that we can be doing better, and sometimes it's very simple. Right? Are you walking? How's your sleep? What are you eating? When's the last time you hung out with somebody that you enjoy spending time with? When's the last time you called one of your friends just to talk about how things are going? Right? Those are things that you can do. I give homework. Some of, sometimes that homework is as simple as, I want you to eat ice cream today, right?
(01:33:06) Justin McMillen: Everybody's going to go see you.
(01:33:08) Brian Choi: Yeah.
(01:33:09) Justin McMillen: No, that's great.
(01:33:11) Brian Choi: But it's something that they can say, okay, I set my mind to it and I did it. And then I can enjoy it. I can push the rest of the stuff out, and there'll be time to address that. But the easy stuff...
(01:33:24) Justin McMillen: The snowball method for, you know, motivation. You throw the small snowball, and then as it builds, it gets bigger and bigger. So you can cross off the small things first and then build up to the bigger things, as opposed to diving in and trying to accomplish the big, humongous task, failing, and then feeling like a failure, and then just staying in bed all day.
(01:33:47) Brian Choi: Yeah. So I give them things that they feel, it's nothing, it's nothing crazy. I just see small things that they haven't had somebody encourage them to do.
(01:33:57) Justin McMillen: Gosh, I love this so much, because again, people who, I, what is it? Do you know what percentage of Americans are on psychiatric medications?
(01:34:07) Brian Choi: It's a lot.
(01:34:08) Justin McMillen: It's a lot. It's a lot. It's, I know it's, it's under 10%, but it's high. It's maybe, no, no, actually, it's probably higher than that.
(01:34:17) Brian Choi: Yeah. I was going to say, I can't remember. I don't want to say the wrong number.
(01:34:22) Justin McMillen: So, high number. So you're a breath of fresh air, because instead of somebody just coming to you to get pills to try to change... You're sitting down with them and you're helping to reprogram their thinking, to help them have agency, and to walk them through some sort of system to understand themselves. And then what I really love about what you're saying is, where are you, what are you aiming for? Right. So how does aiming for something in a person's life change the way that they heal?
(01:34:48) Brian Choi: So, kind of goes back to what we talked about before. I use this image of where people sort of get it wrong in terms of where they're focusing. And this goes back to understanding the problem and doing the research. And a lot of times when you're feeling depressed, when you're feeling anxious, when you're having issues in relationships, you tell yourself, I would rather be anywhere but where I am right now. And that's not a defined goal. It's just, you know how horrible you feel right now. You know that this sucks. You know that this wasn't always how you felt. So you just say, I would rather be, and I want, anything but where I am right now. But the problem with that mentality is that only allows you to sort of circle around the place you don't want to be. You might make it a little bit further from that point one day, but then you don't really have a place you're headed. So then the next day you're right back to where you were. You're circling around. You might make it a little bit further, you might come back a little bit closer. But again, over the long haul, you're just, where were you? Right where you don't want to be. And that's what's frustrating, is like, I want to be someplace else so badly. But day after day, week after week, now it's been months, it's been years, I'm still so close to this feeling of, this is not where I want to be. So then I can work with them to say, okay, let's not focus on that part. Let's focus on, where do you want to be? Who do you want to become? What does it look like when you're in control? What does it look like when you're thriving? What does it look like when you're able to impact the outcome of things? Oftentimes they might not have an answer right away. So then that's okay. It's time to think about that, right? This is a real good opportunity for you to look at and prioritize what's important to you. And then let's come up with some goals. And then when we have a place that we're aiming for, we can work towards getting there. And then if you sort of come back and take a few steps back, it's okay, because now we can compare, hey, that's where we're going. We're moving in the wrong direction now, so we need to correct. Let's learn from why we took a wrong turn, and let's get back on track and start heading towards that goal. And some days you might be making wrong turns over and over again. But we're going to learn from that. And then we're going to correct back on course. And because having a goal allows us to work towards getting there, versus just circling around this nebulous idea of, I want to be anywhere but here.
(01:37:42) Justin McMillen: That's so good. It's like, it's like the brain almost doesn't know anything other than, this is what I'm paying attention to. And if you're paying attention to this very, this idea of, I don't want to be right here, you've got here this thing that is in your mind. You don't want to be, like, you know, you don't want to be that thing. So you're saying circling around it, you're just kind of staying right there, but you're just trying really hard not to be completely out of your mind, or completely depressed, or completely sad. And then that obsession, of course, and it's occupying all of this mental horsepower, or not occupying, requiring all this mental horsepower. It's not allowing you to focus at all on where you actually want to be. And so you're helping... is it hard to get people to dream enough, or to think up what they want to be, without going, I just don't want to be sad?
(01:38:36) Brian Choi: Yeah. Initially, it's, again, working that part of the brain that has not... Not had a lot of action.
(01:38:45) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:38:46) Brian Choi: Right. Going back to this whole efficiency, lazy brain discussion. Right. If you feel that your brain is going to help you achieve your goals, then no wonder you're stuck, because you're going to think, okay, my brain knows that I'm not feeling good, because this is so painful. How can my brain continue to push and push us and keep us stuck when it knows that it's not fun being here? And I've told my brain so many times I want to be someplace else. But that constant, repetitive nature of being in that spot is actually programming that as the autopilot, and in order to get to a different place would require a load of energy, which your brain does not want to do.
(01:39:34) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(01:39:35) Brian Choi: So initially, it's going to be so hard, because your brain is going to actively fight against you for change.
(01:39:44) Justin McMillen: That is very important, what you just said.
(01:39:47) Brian Choi: Because it's going to throw every trick in the book at you, because it says, okay, eventually, I know that I'm not the one that's ultimately in control, but I've enjoyed being in the driver's seat. So if they want to change, I'm going to have to eventually listen to them. But I still don't want to use energy, so maybe I can trick them to stay stuck.
(01:40:10) Justin McMillen: You're describing addiction.
(01:40:13) Brian Choi: Like, yeah, yeah. And whether it's addiction to substances or whether it's this, to, you know, the space that you're in, right? And that's weird to say that, because it's not a fun place to be and you don't want to be there, but you're not looking at it from the standpoint of what the brain wants, the efficiency standpoint, and the fighting against using more energy. And then you're saying, okay, let's anticipate what your brain is going to trick you with, right? Don't reach out to a friend to have dinner with them, because what if they say no? Right. That's another rejection that shows more about you, right? You should have just stayed in bed. Don't go to the gym, because people are going to be looking at you. Right. You haven't been to the gym in how long? Right? All their eyes, all the eyes of the people at the gym are going to be looking at you.
(01:41:05) Justin McMillen: Nobody looks at other people at the, they're looking at themselves.
(01:41:08) Brian Choi: Right.
(01:41:09) Justin McMillen: That's why there's so many mirrors.
(01:41:11) Brian Choi: Right? So the brain is doing all these things to tell you, stay in bed, don't go out, keep doing what you've been doing. And then when you lay in bed and you pull out your phone and you start doom scrolling, your brain is like, takes a deep breath, and it says, we won. We don't have to put energy into this again. We can save that for something else. But once you get to the place where you say, okay, I'm in control, you're going to listen to me, then it has to do what you say. But you have to learn how to change that autopilot and where to focus the energy.
(01:41:47) Justin McMillen: Yeah. And even understanding it. I mean, you're, you're explaining this so beautifully, it makes sense. And I think everybody, you know, you don't have to be somebody who's in the worst position in your life, kind of a thing. It's like we're moving into autopilot mode, or like, as a whole culture. So I think a lot of people listening to this are going to understand exactly what you mean. And what's fascinating about it is you're saying we can get back into control again.
(01:42:16) Brian Choi: Not only back into control, but imagine how powerful it can be once the autopilot is programmed to do what you want it to do.
(01:42:24) Justin McMillen: Right.
(01:42:26) Brian Choi: And that's where you see people actually make long lasting change, achieve long lasting, real sobriety, because they've hardwired and reprogrammed the good habits into their autopilot. So going to the gym, eating healthy, focusing on sleep, doing good behaviors, doing good activities, keeping up with good relationships, is what your brain has now coded as efficient.
(01:42:50) Justin McMillen: Wow. So this, so for somebody who might be trying to do this, as you said, it starts out really hard. They may start really hard. But you would tell them that, like, look, you keep doing this, we're going to get through this hard part. Then it's going to become automatic, and it will become your new default pattern, or whatever. I said earlier, that was probably not the right use case, but it'll, it'll become the thing that you don't have to think about. It'll be the automatic mode.
(01:43:18) Brian Choi: The autopilot.
(01:43:19) Justin McMillen: Yeah.
(01:43:20) Brian Choi: Your autopilot becomes what you choose it to be, versus what your brain thought you wanted it to be based off of your behaviors. Now, there's so much power in that, because then you ask that person, what is the, what is the goal of your brain? You can confidently say, my brain is helping me achieve my goals and is pushing me towards happiness, because that's the programming that I wired into it.
(01:43:44) Justin McMillen: Is there a formula for this, or is it different for everyone?
(01:43:49) Brian Choi: I think it's different for everybody, because what people find important is different. If I focused on spirituality with everybody, for some people it would not...
(01:44:00) Justin McMillen: Not, yeah.
(01:44:01) Brian Choi: If you're going through, if you had a traumatic experience in the past and we don't deal with that, and we're just saying, hey, figure out a goal that you want to achieve, but they have such a damaged view of themselves because of that trauma and what it's said about them... If we don't address that component of it, it doesn't matter. Their goals might be very inconsequential based off of, compared to who they view themselves as.
(01:44:29) Justin McMillen: Sure.
(01:44:30) Brian Choi: And if they don't feel that they're worth it to take control back, they're never going to put in the effort. And the brain is going to win every time, because the brain will tell you you're not worth it every time you go for a change. It knows that if I can just knock down any last bit of confidence that they have, they're going to revert back to isolation. They're going to revert back to, I'm not good enough, there's no point. And then I don't have to use energy. So you have to figure out what the brain knows and what it's going to use to challenge you when you want to change.
(01:45:13) Justin McMillen: Wow.
(01:45:14) Brian Choi: So that's a huge understanding component of it, is, okay, this brain knows you better than I know you. But we need to go... and a lot of times my patients will tell me, when I ask them a difficult question, they'll say, I don't know. And I'll say, okay, every time you tell me, I don't know, I don't necessarily believe you. Not because I think you're lying, but I don't know is a default response, mostly to, I don't want to talk about it. It's too hard. I haven't thought about it.
(01:45:43) Justin McMillen: But it's just a kind of reflex answer.
(01:45:46) Brian Choi: Yeah, because most times when you say I don't know to somebody, they'll ask you another question, so you don't have to think about it. But when somebody says I don't know to me, it actually causes me to stop and say, okay, we need to dive deeper. Yeah, at that point, so that we can understand it, because that could be used against you when we're trying to change.
(01:46:08) Justin McMillen: That's a... are you working on a book?
(01:46:12) Brian Choi: I have, so I recently had our, we recently had our first kid.
(01:46:17) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(01:46:18) Brian Choi: So he's going to be six months soon, at the end of this week. So I'm in, I'm in the trenches.
(01:46:26) Justin McMillen: Okay.
(01:46:27) Brian Choi: But this is, this is kind of the thing.
(01:46:30) Justin McMillen: So it's a boy?
(01:46:32) Brian Choi: Yeah.
(01:46:33) Justin McMillen: Okay. Yeah. Amazing.
(01:46:36) Brian Choi: It's been life changing in so many ways. But one of the, the things that I was thinking about while I was holding him and looking at him was, okay, what do I want to teach him so that he doesn't have to come and see somebody like me in the future? So I'm trying to come up with a lot of these different things that will help... Kids at different stages of their life address some of these difficult things that are not taught in school, and most of the time, the parents are not equipped to teach it, because they haven't addressed it with themselves. But if we can put it in a way, if I can figure out a way to make it so it's digestible, and it gives parents the ability to read a book and see something within themselves, and then be able to impart that on their kids, that, that's kind of ultimately my dream.
(01:47:30) Justin McMillen: Can I get your commitment that when you write this stuff that you'll come back?
(01:47:35) Brian Choi: Absolutely.
(01:47:36) Justin McMillen: It's, I, I think you're going to do so well with this. I, I think it's so important, because a lot of...
(01:47:43) Brian Choi: Along this journey, a lot of my patients have told me, like, how come I haven't, how come no one's talking like this? How come I haven't learned this? Why aren't, why aren't we teaching people about this? Because it seems very simple, and it's so powerful once you can wrap your mind around it and start practicing it. So I, I've really been thinking about the best way to approach this, and it's evolving.
(01:48:08) Justin McMillen: Well, that's part of why we reached out to you, because I think the goal is to catch you guys, you guys being some of the people that are going to be influential. I feel like I have a decent sense of where things are going, in terms of... I mean, that's a, that's a really bold statement. I think certain things are headed in a direction. I think mental health, there's no question that this is going to be a forefront subject in our country. If we don't get this right, we're screwed. Like, this is a national security issue. It's the fate of our whole system. It's our children. It's the root cause of so many things. So I see you guys as being the most important subject. That's why I interview so many people in the mental health space. It's not just because I work in addiction treatment. And then within that space you have, like, and it's not anyone's fault, it's a system, but you have like 90% or more... That's an arbitrary number, I'm just throwing it out, but just to give you an idea of my sense, of mass, are really kind of doing the protocol, the standard way of doing things. You get to this outside edge and you find people like you who are doing things different, and I'm certain that it's just a matter of time before your, your career is going to blow up. You're going to be a public figure in this space. And so I'm glad that I got to catch you early in this, and I, anything that I can do to support you moving forward, whether it be, you know, promoting your, your books as you write them... certainly you're going to become more of a face in, in the social media, YouTube, and this whole digital sphere. And I'll tell you why. I'm just going to make a prediction right now. It's because you are able to explain things in a very simple and clear way. And a lot of times people hide behind complicated. They think complicated means better. It's not true. I meet a ton of super smart people. I know, I know what it looks like when somebody really got their hands on something. And your frame right now is beautiful, so you need to be more visible. I'm going to do whatever I can to help promote that, and I'm really excited to ride your coattails as you come up, to say, I was the first, one of the first guys that got him on our show. So Doctor Brian Choi, thank you very much for being here.
(01:50:19) Brian Choi: It's been, it's been a pleasure, Justin. And, I really appreciate those words. I, my, I've never had big ambitions to, like, you know, change the world. I've always wanted to find the people that come into my sphere and be able to help them as much as I can. And while, you know, as doing this, it's so rewarding having people experience what I was able to experience, from going without hope to then having that hope. And I've told a lot of my patients, in this relationship, only one of us has to have hope. You right now don't have hope, but I have hope for you, and that's sometimes enough to get them one step forward. And I will be there with you until you can say that you have hope. So this has been a really great experience.
(01:51:18) Justin McMillen: Yeah, and I've enjoyed this conversation so much.
(01:51:20) Brian Choi: I have too.
(01:51:21) Justin McMillen: And I'm so glad you exist. So thank you for everything you're doing.
(01:51:24) Brian Choi: You're welcome. Thank you.
(01:51:26) Justin McMillen: Beautiful.
Contact us
Interested in working together? Fill out some info and we will be in touch shortly. We can’t wait to hear from you!